Lufthansa’s Miles & More “Cash & Miles” Option Offers Terrible Value!

Some links to products and travel providers on this website will earn Traveling For Miles a commission which helps contribute to the running of the site – I’m very grateful to anyone who uses these links but their use is entirely optional. The compensation does not impact how and where products appear on this site and does not impact reviews that are published.

On Friday I published news that Lufthansa had introduced a Cash & Miles option for customers who wanted to pay or part pay for a cash ticket using their Miles & More miles. At the time of writing I couldn’t see just what sort of value customers could get from their miles if they used them for Cash & Miles purchases but, over the weekend, things got a lot clearer and the news is anything but good.

Firstly it’s important to point out that “Cash & Miles” purchases are not taking the place of the existing Miles & More awards which are booked wholly with miles. The regular Miles & More awards are still in place and haven’t changed in any way.

Here’s the award chart for anyone that’s interested (click thumbnail to enlarge)

miles-and-more-award-chart

The “Cash & Miles” purchases are supposed to give flyers an additional way to use their Miles & More balances – put simply, a value has been given to a Miles & More mile and customers can now use their miles to reduce the price of a regular cash ticket.

On the face of things this sounds great.

  • Because the miles are being used to purchase a cash ticket you don’t have to wait for award availability to open up – as long a there’s seat for sale on the aircraft customers can use miles to pay (or part pay) for that seat.
  • Because part-payment are allowed customers are not limited by the number of miles in their accounts (as long as they have a minimum of 7,000 miles to use).

Unfortunately, while the above two points remain correct, it turns out that value that has been assigned to a mile makes “Cash and Miles” option a very bad deal for almost all travelers.

screen-shot-2016-11-18-at-15-47-14

I still don’t have any miles in my Miles & More account so I can’t see what sort of discount the miles will offer….but a lot of other people have checked this out and the answer isn’t good.

Cash & Miles purchases appear to be valuing Miles & More miles at around 0.5 cents each…and that’s terrible value.

A Miles & More Business Class award flight between the US and Europe will cost 105,000 miles roundtrip and, as you can see from this randomly selected set of dates, a JFK to Frankfurt roundtrip will cost around $2,500:screen-shot-2016-11-18-at-15-57-11

At $0.005/mile this Business Class flight would cost 498,586 miles if booked using the Cash & Miles option.

That’s 393,586 miles more than the regular Miles & More award.

Ok, there are two downsides to  Miles & More awards…..

  • You have to find award availability
  • You have to pay taxes and fees of around $620 on the award

…and there is an upside to the Cash & Miles award:

  • Cash & Miles awards are eligible for elite and mileage earning

But Cash & Miles awards are still terrible value.

If you assume that $2,500 is a fair price for a Lufthansa Business Class roundtrip ticket then, allowing for the $620 in fees you have to pay on the award, 105,ooo miles is getting you $1,880 of value.

That’s equivalent to 1.8 cents per mile or over 3.5x the value you get from a Cash & Miles award.

Bottom Line

If you have more Miles & More miles than you can possibly use or if you only have a few miles in your account and there’s little prospect of adding to them, then using the new Cash & Miles option may be a good idea to save some money. Otherwise it’s a bad proposition.

You would be far better waiting for a regular award to open up and using your miles that way rather than squandering them at 0.5 cents each.